GP Short Notes

GP Short Notes # 654, 7 August 2022

Ukraine: Amnesty condemns civilian cover tactics in urban warfare
Angelin Archana

Ukraine: Amnesty condemns civilian cover tactics in urban warfare 

What happened? 
On August 4th, 2022, Amnesty International released a report accusing the Ukrainian government of using civilians as a cover in the ongoing war. The organization examined strike sites, interviewed survivors, and victims who lost their family members, conducted remote sensing in warzones, and assessed weapon technology used by both sides. 

Amnesty had condemned Russia’s act of aggression that unleashed the human rights and refugee crisis in Europe since World War II, apart from various war crimes and the use of banned weapons such as cluster bombs. Nevertheless, it became a heated debate, when the organization convicted Ukraine and stated, “Being in a defensive position does not exempt the Ukrainian military from respecting international humanitarian law,” as Ukraine had launched retaliatory attacks on Russian soldiers from the residential areas, civilian buildings, and the backyard of the houses, agricultural warehouses, schools, and hospitals. 

The Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky slammed Amnesty International for not designating Russian atrocities as acts of terror, immoral selectivity between aggressor and victim, and the report to be bizarre and misleading. Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba tweeted that the report distorts reality, boosts Russia’s disinformation efforts, initiates false moral equivalence between the aggressor and victim, and further accuses Amnesty of fake neutrality and truthfulness. Ukraine’s Minister of Defense Oleksii Reznikov claimed it to be a perversion. Numerous people, including the British and US Ambassadors, have condemned the report and called it manipulative. 

Subsequently, there was a spur of footage on Russian atrocities on social media, which claimed Russia and not Ukraine to be endangering civilians. Amnesty International’s Secretary General Agnes Callamard criticized both Ukrainian and Russian netizen views on the matter as “social media mobs and trolls,” terming their actions as war propaganda, disinformation, and misinformation, thus justifying its impartiality in the investigation.

What is the background? 
First, the violation of international laws of armed conflict. The International Humanitarian Law, laws of armed conflict, or laws of war, is a set of rules to wage war based on humanity, impartiality, and neutrality, created through four Geneva Conventions and three additional protocols, which were adopted in 1949 by all nations in the world. The third Geneva Convention exclusively calls for civilians’ protection in war zones, which articulates against civilian hostages, less damage to civilian objects, or execution without proper judgments. The first protocol mentions three principles of IHL: principles of distinction, proportionality, and precautions.

In the report, Amnesty accuses Ukraine of violating these principles by inspecting 19 towns and villages from April to July across multiple regions of Ukraine. The organization disclosed that Ukrainian soldiers used civilian homes in Donbas, Kharkiv, and Mykolaiv regions to attack the Russian soldiers. Amnesty visited 29 school campuses, of which 22 were used as military bases, in Bakhmut, a university building, farmlands, and hospitals in five different locations were also used as military bases, thereby deliberately causing civilian collateral damage.

Second, Urban Warfare. In Mosul, the US-backed Iraqi security conducted a full-scale city attack from October 2016 to January 2017. However, it is a high-risk tactic, as the war ended by killing thousands of civilians, millions of tons of debris, hindering essential services, and millions displaced, permanently altering the landscape and causing more harm to humans and the environment within a short period. Similar conflicts were witnessed in Damascus, Aleppo, Raqqa, and Palmyra, whereas Ukrainian cities are its latest examples. This violates the principle of distinction, especially using unguided artillery, mortars, multi-barrel rocket launchers, large bombs, and missiles. At the beginning of the war, Ukraine diluted the hostilities status by providing arms to the civilians. The principle of distinction does not encourage attacking or using civilian infrastructure and condemns the spread of terror amongst the civilians, irrespective of aggressor and victim.  

What does it mean? 
Amnesty claimed that Ukraine followed a pattern of civilian cover, and thus Ukraine breached the IHL. However, the central idea is the changing nature of warfare by the incorporation of civilian structures without differentiating between the victim and the aggressor. IHL advocates war in barren territories, during the day, without disturbing the civilian livelihood, which is eroding since the induction of urban warfare. 

The principle of proportionality demands an assessment of the operation based on civilian loss or damage and calls for the cancellation of the attack. Precautions are to avoid armed conflict near civilians and military objectives near densely populated areas, which the Ukrainian soldiers violated. Therefore, there is a need for neutral players grounded with IHL, or it will reduce the scope of humanity, impartiality, humanitarian activities, negotiations, and mediations during warfare. However, with violence harbouring in residential areas, and weapons at civilian disposal, there is a probability of Ukraine converting into the New Middle East with collapsed human development, if civilian livelihood is ceaselessly disrupted. 

31 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 730
Colombia: One year of “total peace” plan
26 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 728
Niger: Continuing standoff
20 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 727
Ethiopia: Another conflict in Amhara

20 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 726
Moscow conference on international security
17 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 724
Hawaii: The wildfires
17 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 723
Ecuador: Increasing political violence

13 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 722
Amazon Summit: A united front for saving the rainforest
13 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 721
Japan-Australia's Reciprocal Access Agreement
10 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 719
The War in Ukraine: Escalation after drone attacks

10 August 2023 | GP Short Notes # 718
Niger: Standoff after the coup
27 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 717
Protests over Judicial Reforms in Israel
27 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 716
Kenya: Anti-government protests turn violent
27 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 715
Niger: Another Coup 

20 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 713
Syria: Stalemate over Aid extension
6 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 709
Israel: Violence in Jenin
6 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 708
Mali: Termination of the UN Mission - MINUSMA
2 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 706
Pakistan: Finally, a deal with the IMF
2 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 705
France: Summit for a New Global Financing Pact 
2 July 2023 | GP Short Notes # 704
New High Seas Treaty: Beyond National Jurisdiction 
29 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 703
Sudan: Nine Ceasefires, No Solution in Sight

29 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 702
Russia: Rise and Fall of the Wagner Revolt
25 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 701
Russia: Anatomy of Wagner Revolt, and its Fallouts
22 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 699
Greece: Migrant boat disaster and humanitarian crisis

22 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 698
Uganda: Resurging insurgency
11 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 696
The Debt crisis in Pakistan
11 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 695
Domestic instability in Colombia

11 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 694
Political Crises in Maldives
8 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 693
Canada: Raging Wildfires and its fallouts
5 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 692
The US: Debt Ceiling Notches up higher
5 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 691
Turkey's Election: Erdogan's reign to continue

5 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 690
North Korea: Nuclear, Missile and now Space
1 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 687
Violence in Kosovo: Dangers of Escalation
1 June 2023 | GP Short Notes # 686
Russia and Ukraine: A New Drone Warfare

28 May 2023 | GP Short Notes # 684
G7 Summit: Unity, Polarization and Challenges
28 May 2023 | GP Short Notes # 683
Thailand elections: Victory of democracy
25 May 2023 | GP Short Notes # 681
Ukraine: Russia claims victory in Bakhmut
25 May 2023 | GP Short Notes # 680
Sudan: A Seventh Ceasefire
25 May 2023 | GP Short Notes # 679
Arab League: The Return of Syria
16 April 2023 | GP Short Notes # 673
France: Contended pension reform bill becomes law
9 April 2023 | GP Short Notes # 671
OPEC: Reducing crude oil production
9 April 2023 | GP Short Notes # 670
Space: NASA announces crew for the Artemis II mission

9 April 2023 | GP Short Notes # 698
France and China: The Macron-Xi meeting
2 April 2023 | GP Short Notes # 697
NATO: Turkey greenlights Finland’s membership
2 April 2023 | GP Short Notes # 696
Expanding Russia-South Africa relations

19 March 2023 | GP Short Notes # 694
AUKUS Submarine Deal
19 March 2023 | GP Short Notes # 693
Saudi Arabia: Resumption of diplomatic ties with Iran
8 March 2023 | GP Short Notes # 692
Macron’s visit to Africa: Three Takeaways

Click below links for year wise archive
2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | 2018

Click here for old Short Notes