NIAS Area Studies


PAKISTAN READER

Photo Source:
   NIAS Course on Global Politics
National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS)
Indian Institute of Science Campus, Bangalore
For any further information or to subscribe to GP alerts send an email to subachandran@nias.res.in

Trump-Kim Summit
No deal is better, but isn't it bad?

  Harini Madhusudan

The Hanoi summit is not a failure but was simply premature.

Research Associate, ISSSP, NIAS

 

The dramatic end to the highly anticipated Hanoi summit, speaks volumes about the ‘romanticized’ relations between President Donald Trump and Supreme leader of North Korea, Kim Jong Un. The summit has been revelatory in many ways but the question remains,  is the lapse of the summit an end to the diplomatic efforts between the United States and North Korea, or just an end to the portrayed “positive” relations between the two leaders? What are the lessons learnt from the mutual misjudgement of interests from both the parties? What are the gains and losses?

The doors for further diplomatic efforts have not been completely closed. After a conscious decision by the US, along with South Korea, they suspended the scheduled springtime military drills and announced that it would be replaced by smaller exercises in an effort to support the talks. There is an allegation that the North Korean hackers attacked ‘critical infrastructure’ in the US during the summit. Alongside this, was the court hearing of Michael Cohen. Certainly, all these factors have had a particular impact on the lapse of the summit.

 

Lessons Learnt

 

First, it was a stretch to expect a join statement from this summit. Though the Singapore summit set the bar high with the signing of the joint communique.   Both the parties signed an agreement with 4 guarantees; creating a new relationship by establishing liaison offices, building a peace regime starting with a peace declaration, working toward denuclearization essentially by reducing fissile material production and returning more soldiers’ remains from the Korean War. However, none of these materialised and there were no details on how the goals were to be achieved.

 

Second, it does not mean that Trump is unaware of what he has done, he is a businessman and he certainly understands how beneficial deals are made. Trump exit the summit saying, ‘sometimes we have to walk away.’ Both Kim and Trump, by taking the negotiations to the highest level tried to make it a historic achievement of their own personalities, evidently underscoring the dangers of over personalising negotiations. To the end, the leaders remained glued to their maximalist nation-centric interests.

 

What is interesting to note is that, Trump stuck to his original plan of a commitment to complete denuclearisation while Kim tried to offer the closing of the Yongbyun nuclear facility in exchange for ‘partial’ removal of sanctions. Maybe both the sides should have waited for a minimally accepted deal in the negotiations at the lower levels of diplomacy before Hanoi. The advisors of Trump did request for the summit to be postponed because they felt it was too early.

 

Third, both the sides clearly misjudged the other, Trump more. The attitude of the US towards the DPRK nuclear programme can be associated to what is called the, ‘hegemonic alliance ideology of nuclear deterrence.’ This is seen as coercive.  The strategic interests of the American presence in the region, is strongly based on the threat from DPRK. If a deal were to be made, then there would be no relevance to the US presence in South Korea. Kim, on the other hand, has the challenge of dual survival. Survival of his regime and survival of himself. Kim has seen what the US has done in the case of Saddam Hussein, and Muammar al-Gaddafi. The Hanoi summit was indeed very early for both the sides to reach consensus on critical interests. Any joint agreement that would have come from this summit would be extremely challenging to implement.

 

Who loses the most?

 

Hanoi Summit would go down as an attempt in furthering ‘confidence building’ between the nations. “No Deal” is seen as a relief among many in security circles. Many US senators from both the parties said that they back the tough negotiating stance of Trump toward Pyongyang. It showed that the Trump administration has a clear strategy on their mind. There was strong public opinion that Trump wasted time and resources trying to make a deal with someone who never intended to. Nonetheless, The United States failed to get DPRK to open their markets to American companies. This is not the first time that the US and DPRK have disagreed to work together and certainly it will not be the last.

 

Only an unbalanced deal will come from the negotiations between the two countries. As a negotiator, Trump did not rush into a deal this time and it showed a sign of maturity in his approach. Did Trump lose face to Kim’s tactics? No. But getting Kim to the negotiating table, two times in two years itself is a huge gain for Trump. By walking away from the summit, Trump has ensured that his approach to DPRK remains one of his international successes as the President. This failure of US and success of Trump should both be noted.

 

South Korea’s president Moon Jae-in is one of the losers of the Hanoi summit because he cannot move forward with peace-building without meaningful progress toward denuclearization. The conflict on the Korean Peninsula would not have endured for 70 years if its solution was obvious. This was going to be the crowning moment for Moon Jae-in to show the success of his engagement strategy.

 

China continues to show optimism in the negotiation efforts between the US and DPRK. Kim rode a 60-hour China train to Hanoi. This was more than just a journey. It symbolised that Kim is supported and been provided security by China. Despite playing a dormant role in the two summits, China has re-emphasised that the hermit kingdom can not be dealt with, without China. It is interesting to note that, Kim Jong-un’s father Kim Jong-il’s also prefered trains. Kim Jong-il had a fear of flying, so he went almost everywhere by rail. When he died in 2011, he is said to have died on one of these special trains. Consider the extraordinary measures it took to foster Mr. Kim’s train journey to Vietnam.

 

China, North Korea and South Korea all have a common interest and that is the removal of US troops from South Korea. Vietnam managed to gain the attention of the US but failed to get its glorious moment of solving the dispute. Moscow is disappointed because it is keen to retract the sanctions that they have imposed on DPRK.

 

“No deal is better than a bad deal,” and this is true in the case of the dynamics in the relations between the two countries and the leaders. Both Trump and Kim have very strong personalities. The two summits have been successful in bringing them together and encouraging interactions. This means that the two of them understand each other better than they did when they called each other ‘madman,’ but still not enough to promise complete rollback on nuclear programme in exchange for complete removal of sanctions. However, the Hanoi summit is not a failure but was simply premature.

 

Since there is not much change in the dynamics, the sanctions will remain the factor that will drive the actions of Kim’s regime and the 2020 election- Trump’s policies. The decision to go slow on the military exercise and the allegation that DPRK has begun work on its ‘Sohae’ long range rocket launch site, makes the situation unpredictable at this point because Sohae launch site which is located at Tongchang-ri is the location that was promised to be shut down in the Singapore summit.  This site has been used in the past for satellite launches, which use ICBM technology that is banned under UN Security Council resolutions. This can be seen as a provocation attempt of DPRK by the United States.

A version of the above commentary was first published in the Rising Kashmir

Print Bookmark

June 2026 | CWA # 2132

Brighty Ann Sarah | Brighty Ann Sarah is a Research Assistant with the Global Politics team at the Science, Technology and International Relations (STIR) Programme at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

The US-Iran War, Week Fourteen:
June 2026 | CWA # 2131

Rohini Reenum | Rohini Reenum is a doctoral student at NIAS. She is working on Governance in Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction using the case study of the BBNJ Agreement.

Israel-Lebanon Tensions:
June 2026 | CWA # 2130

Akshath Kaimal | Akshath Kaimal is a Research Assistant at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru, and is part of the NIAS Pakistan Reader and Africa Studies teams.

The UK-Rwanda Asylum Deal: 
June 2026 | CWA # 2129

Anu Maria Joseph | Anu Maria Joseph is currently a Non-Resident Fellow, Subhas Chandra Bose International Relations (SCB-IR) Chair, Chanakya University, Bengaluru.

Conflicts in Africa This Week:
May 2026 | CWA # 2127

Madhura Meenakshi Tanikella | Madhura Meenakshi Tanikella is an undergraduate from the Department of Political Science, School of Liberal Arts, Alliance University, Bengaluru

The Quad Foreign Ministers' Meeting 2026:
May 2026 | CWA # 2126

Aparna A Nair | Aparna A Nair is a graduate from the Department of Political Science, Madras Christian College, Chennai.

The Shenzhou-23 Mission:
May 2026 | CWA # 2124

Glynnis Winona B | Glynnis Winona B is an undergraduate student at the Department of International Relations, Peace Studies, and Public Policy, St. Joseph's University, Bengaluru. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengalur

The Crisis in Cuba:
May 2026 | CWA # 2123

Akshath Kaimal | Akshath Kaimal is a Research Associate at NIAS and is part of the NIAS Pakistan Reader and Africa Studies teams.

The Ebola and the DR Congo:
May 2026 | CWA # 2122

Radhika M Agarwal | Radhika M Agarwal is a postgraduate student at the Department of Politics and International Relations in Pandit Deendayal Energy University, Gandhinagar.

The War in Ukraine:
May 2026 | CWA # 2121

Deb Dutta | Deb Dutta completed his graduation from the Department of Political Science, Sir Aurobindo International Centre of Education (SAICE), Puducherry. He is currently an intern at NIAS.

Israel, Lebanon, Hezbollah, and the Border Tensions:
May 2026 | CWA # 2120

Brighty Ann Sarah | Brighty Ann Sarah is a Research Assistant with the Global Politics team at the Science, Technology and International Relations (STIR) Programme at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

Conflicts in the Middle East
May 2026 | CWA # 2119

Anu Maria Joseph | Anu Maria Joseph is currently a Non-Resident Fellow, Subhas Chandra Bose International Relations (SCB-IR) Chair, Chanakya University, Bengaluru.

Conflicts in Africa
May 2026 | CWA # 2116

Yesasvi Koganti | Yesasvi Koganti is currently pursuing undergraduate studies at the Department of Political Science, Madras Christian College, Chennai. 

India, the UAE, and PM Modi’s visit:
May 2026 | CWA # 2115

Aparna A Nair | Aparna A Nair is a research intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies, Bengaluru.

The Putin-Xi Summit
May 2026 | CWA # 2114

Glynnis Winona B | Glynnis Winona B is an undergraduate student at the Department of International Relations, Peace Studies and Public Policy, St. Joseph's University, Bengaluru. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru

What makes the UAE a global player?
May 2026 | CWA # 2113

Aishal Hab Yousuf | Aishal Hab Yousuf is a postgraduate student at the Department of International Studies, Stella Maris College, Chennai. She is currently an intern at NIAS, Bengaluru.

Sri Lanka and the US-Iran War 
May 2026 | CWA # 2112

Nithin V | Nithin V is a postgraduate student in international relations at Loyola College, Chennai. He is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

Why does the Falkland Islands dispute keep recurring?
May 2026 | CWA # 2110

Aishal Hab Yousuf | Aishal Hab Yousuf is a postgraduate student at the Department of International Studies, Stella Maris College, Chennai. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

The Trump-Xi Summit:
May 2026 | CWA # 2109

Aishal Hab Yousuf | Aishal Hab Yousuf is a postgraduate student at the Department of International Studies, Stella Maris College, Chennai. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

North Korea's Constitutional Amendment 2026:
May 2026 | CWA # 2108

Ada Khan | Ada Khan is an undergraduate at the Department of Political Science, Public Policy, and Media Studies, Mount Carmel College, Bengaluru.

The Africa Forward Summit 2026:
May 2026 | CWA # 2104

Brighty Ann Sarah | Brighty Ann Sarah is a Research Assistant with the Global Politics team at the Science, Technology and International Relations (STIR) Programme at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

The Israel-Lebanon Ceasefire:
May 2026 | CWA # 2091

Brighty Ann Sarah | Brighty Ann Sarah is a Research Assistant with the Global Politics team at the Science, Technology and International Relations (STIR) Programme at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

Conflicts in the Middle East:
May 2026 | CWA # 2090

Brighty Ann Sarah | Brighty Ann Sarah is a Research Assistant with the Global Politics team at the Science, Technology and International Relations (STIR) Programme at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

The US-Iran War, Week Ten:
May 2026 | CWA # 2088

Nithin V | Nithin V is a postgraduate student in International Relations, with an interest in geopolitics, international political economy, and climate governance. He is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

King Charles's US Visit:
May 2026 | CWA # 2087

Siddhi Halyur | Siddhi Halyur is an undergraduate student at the Department of International Relations, Public Policy and Journalism at St Joseph's University, Bengaluru. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

Japan, Vietnam and PM Takaichis Visit
May 2026 | CWA # 2086

Aishal Hab Yousuf | Aishal Hab Yousuf is a postgraduate student at the Department of International Studies, Stella Maris College, Chennai. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

UAEs Exit from OPEC:
May 2026 | CWA # 2085

Glynnis Winona B | Glynnis Winona B is an undergraduate student at the Department of International Relations, Peace Studies and Public Policy, St. Joseph's University, Bengaluru. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru

US troop withdrawal from Germany:
May 2026 | CWA # 2083

Brighty Ann Sarah | Brighty Ann Sarah is a Research Assistant with the Global Politics team at the Science, Technology and International Relations (STIR) Programme at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

The US-Iran War, Week Nine:
May 2026 | CWA # 2081

Jenin Raj S | Dr Jenin Raj S is an Assistant Professor and Head of the Centre for Media, Department of Journalism, Mount Carmel College (Autonomous), Bengaluru.

Media freedom hits a 25-year low:
April 2026 | CWA # 2079

Aishal Hab Yousuf | Aishal Hab Yousuf, Postgraduate student, Department of International Studies, Stella Maris College, Chennai. She is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.

Japans New Defence Posture:
April 2026 | CWA # 2074

Brighty Ann Sarah | Ms Sarah is a Research Assistant at NIAS and Assistant Editor of NIAS Conflict Weekly.

Israel-Lebanon Ceasefire:
April 2026 | CWA # 2073

Akshath Kaimal | Mr Kaimal is a Research Assistant at NIAS. He works on Pakistan and Africa.

The US-Iran War, Week Eight:
April 2026 | CWA # 2065

Lakshmi Venugopal Menon | Dr Lakshmi Venugopal Menon is an academic and policy researcher specializing in Gulf studies, cultural heritage trafficking, geopolitics, migration, Afghan politics and the Taliban.

The Middle East (JanMar 2026):
February 2026 | CWA # 1959

Yesasvi Koganti | Yesasvi Koganti is an undergraduate student from Madras Christian College, Chennai.

UK and China
February 2026 | CWA # 1957

R Preetha | R Preetha is pursuing post-graduation in the Department of International Studies, Stella Maris College, Chennai, and is a Research Assistant at the National Institute of Advanced Studies, Bengaluru.

The IndiaUS interim trade framework
February 2026 | CWA # 1956

Lekshmi MK | Lekshmi MK is pursuing post-graduation in the Department of Political Science, Madras Christian College, Chennai, and is a Research Assistant at the National Institute of Advanced Studies, Bengaluru.

End of the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (START)
August 2025 | CWA # 1780

Abhiruchi Chowdhury

Trump tariffs:
June 2025 | CWA # 1694

Aashish Ganeshan

The US:
May 2025 | CWA # 1688

Ayan Datta

Gaza
May 2025 | CWA # 1675

Lekshmi MK

Turkey:
May 2025 | CWA # 1673

Padmashree Anandhan

Ukraine:
May 2025 | CWA # 1667

R Preetha and Brighty Ann Sarah

East Asia:
September 2019 | CWA # 162

Lakshman Chakravarthy N

5G: A Primer
December 2018 | CWA # 71

Mahesh Bhatta | Centre for South Asian Studies, Kathmandu

Nepal
December 2018 | CWA # 70

Nasima Khatoon | Research Associate, ISSSP, NIAS

The Maldives
December 2018 | CWA # 69

Harini Madhusudan | Research Associate, ISSSP, NIAS

India
December 2018 | CWA # 68

Sourina Bej | Research Associate, ISSSP, NIAS

Bangladesh
December 2018 | CWA # 67

Seetha Lakshmi Dinesh Iyer | Research Associate, ISSSP, NIAS

Afghanistan