Photo Source:
National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS)
Indian Institute of Science Campus, Bangalore
For any further information or to subscribe to GP alerts send an email to subachandran@nias.res.in
PR Explainer
Politics of New Provinces in Pakistan:
|
Abhimanyu Solanki
|
On 5 September, Dawn reported that the Interior Minister, in his address to the National Policy Dialogue in Lahore, called for a reset of Pakistan’s governance systems to address decades-old failures in public service delivery. He called for the creation of new provinces and administrative units in Pakistan and stressed that the creation of new provinces would have to be carried out within the framework of the Constitution. He asserted that the decision should not be imposed by any government or political party but should be based on the will of the people. As a result, renewed public debate emerged over the creation of new provinces and administrative units in Pakistan.
On 4 September, Dawn reported that the Sindh Assembly adopted a resolution rejecting all attempts to divide the province or create new administrative units, amid strong protests and a boycott by the opposition. The opposition party MQM-P demanded the empowerment of existing administrative units, as it believed that financial, administrative and political powers should be devolved to divisions, including Karachi, Hyderabad, Shaheed Benazirabad and Larkana. During the resolution debate, CM Syed Murad Ali Shah declared that there would be no compromise on Sindh’s geographical integrity.
What does the Constitution say about new provinces?
Article 239(4) of Pakistan’s Constitution is the central provision with regard to the debate on new provinces. It states that any constitutional amendment altering the territorial boundaries of a province requires the approval of at least two-thirds of the total membership of the affected provincial assembly, in addition to the constitutionally required two-thirds majorities in the National Assembly and the Senate. A referendum is not prescribed as a mandatory part of this constitutional procedure.
Furthermore, the 18th Constitutional Amendment of 2010 plays an indirect role in the debate on new provinces. It reoriented federal-provincial relations and strengthened provincial autonomy by transferring legislative authority over several subjects to the provinces. Separately, the Seventh National Finance Commission (NFC) Award increased the provincial share in the divisible pool. However, these developments did not resolve the question of autonomy within provinces.
What are the demands for new provinces in Pakistan?
In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, there is a demand for a new province in the Hazara region. The demand for a Hazara province has been largely raised by Hindko-speaking communities. It is closely connected to questions of regional identity, political representation, provincial autonomy and the consequences of Pakistan’s 18th Constitutional Amendment of 2010. The immediate trigger was the renaming of the North-West Frontier Province (NWFP) as Khyber Pakhtunkhwa under the 18th Constitutional Amendment. Hazara groups argued that the new name did not adequately reflect their regional identity. The demand has been raised by groups such as Tehreek Sooba Hazara (TSH) and Sooba Hazara Tehreek (SHT).
In the case of Sindh, there is a demand for a new province among sections of the Mohajir community. Mohajirs are Urdu-speaking Muslim migrants who moved from different parts of British India to Pakistan during Partition in 1947 and whose descendants predominantly reside in urban Sindh, particularly Karachi and Hyderabad. The demand is advanced by the Muttahida Qaumi Movement–Pakistan (MQM-P). It proposes a new provincial unit for the major urban centres of Sindh.
In the case of Punjab, there is a demand for a new Saraiki province, which would largely comprise the southern parts of Punjab. The major factors behind the demand for new provinces include the alleged neglect of infrastructure, education and healthcare in the southern districts of Punjab.
Politics around the creation of new provinces: The case of Punjab
The role of political parties in the demand for new provinces can be analysed through a study of the manifestos of major parties in the 2013, 2018 and 2024 elections. In the case of the PPP, its 2013 manifesto embraced the demand for new provinces as a pathway towards national harmony and inclusive democracy. It argued that, for all practical purposes, power should be distributed and that the creation of new provinces was a step in the right direction. It also included a section on the Bahawalpur–Junoobi Punjab province.
Similarly, in the 2018 elections, the PPP’s manifesto focused exclusively on a new province in South Punjab and made no reference to the creation of other provinces. In 2024, it reiterated the same demand. The PML-N supported the creation of a new province for South Punjab. However, its manifesto did not explain the criteria for the proposed province, whether ethnic or administrative. In the 2024 elections, it remained silent on the question of a new province. In 2018, the PTI also called for the creation of South Punjab, but on administrative lines. Hence, the PPP is the only party among these three that consistently reiterated its support for a new province in South Punjab across the three election cycles.
Secondly, the major political parties have generally framed their support for new provinces in administrative rather than explicitly ethnic terms. The political debate also raises questions about why the PPP supports the demand for a new province in Punjab but opposes the division of Sindh, and why the PML-N has not consistently pursued the creation of a new province in Punjab. One possible explanation lies in electoral gains and the parties’ strongholds in different regions. The PPP’s opposition to dividing Sindh may be linked to its stronghold in Sindh politics. Similarly, the PML-N’s approach to the division of Punjab may be influenced by its established political position in the province.
To Conclude
The issue of new provinces has been politicised by certain political parties for narrow electoral and constituency-based gains. Political elites are often motivated by electoral considerations. The creation of new provinces also presents fiscal and administrative challenges for a federation already experiencing numerous problems on internal and external fronts.
The constitutional provisions make the creation of new provinces politically difficult in today’s political landscape. Over time, regional groups have increasingly pursued their demands through constitutional means. However, securing the required legislative majorities for the creation of new provinces remains a significant challenge.
The debate over new provinces may be less prominent in the manifestos of some major political parties, but this does not necessarily mean that regional demands are declining. The PPP’s continued support for a South Punjab province in its 2024 manifesto highlights the persistence of the issue. Furthermore, even if new provinces are created on administrative lines, the process is likely to remain controversial, as political parties may attempt to influence territorial boundaries in ways that favour their electoral interests in upcoming elections.
References
1. “Naqvi says new administrative units to be formed only with people's consent,” Dawn, 05 September 2026
2. “Sindh Assembly adopts resolution against division of province amid opposition boycott,” Dawn, 04 September 2026
3. “Resolution opposing the division of Sindh,” Provincial Assembly of Sindh, 2026
4. “Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan,” National Assembly of Pakistan. See Article 239(4).
5. “Constitution (Eighteenth Amendment) Act, 2010,” Government of Pakistan, 2010
6. “Manifesto 2013,” Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians, 2013
7. “Election Manifesto 2018,” Pakistan Peoples Party, 2018
8. “Election Manifesto 2024,” Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians, 2024
9. “The Road to Naya Pakistan: PTI Manifesto 2018,” Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, 2018
10. “Election Manifesto 2024,” Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, 2024
11. “Election Manifesto 2024,” Pakistan Muslim League–Nawaz, 2024
12. “Develop national consensus on the creation of South Punjab province,” Dawn, 29 October 2018
13. “Commission recommends new ‘Bahawalpur Janoobi Punjab’ province,” Dawn, 1 February 2013
14. “Assembly backs South Punjab, Bahawalpur provinces,” Dawn, 10 May 2012
| |
Bookmark |
Preetha Renganarayanan | Preetha Renganarayanan is a Research Assistant at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.
Pakistan and the World Bank Report on AI, Jobs and Growth
Advik Sunanda Mohan | Advik Sunanda Mohan is a postgraduate student at the Paris School of International Affairs, Sciences Po. He is currently a Research Intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies.
The Moscow Consultations and the Afghanistan-Pakistan Conflict:
Vani Vyshnavi Jupudi
UN Secretary General's Pakistan visit:
Abhimanyu Solanki
Politics of New Provinces in Pakistan:
Lekshmi MK | Lekshmi MK is a Research Assistant at the National Institute of Advanced Studies, Bengaluru
Pakistan's Climate Crisis and Economic Vulnerabilities:
Namrata L Ghanghatkar | Namrata L Ghanghatkar is a postgraduate student at the Department of Public Policy, Ramaiah University of Applied Sciences, Bengaluru. She is currently a research intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS).
Pakistan reaches another IMF Deal:
Akshath Kaimal | Akshath Kaimal is a Research Assistant at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru, and is part of the NIAS Pakistan Reader team.
Emergency in Pakistan's Khyber Pakhtunkhwa:
Vani Vyshnavi Jupudi
The Makkah Agreement and Pakistan's Economy:
Abhimanyu Solanki
Pakistan's External Labour Migration:
Radhika M Agarwal | Radhika M Agarwal is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies and is a postgraduate student in the department of Politics and International Relations at Pandit Deendayal Energy University, Gandhinagar.
Pakistan's Blue Economy Crisis:
Madhura Meenakshi Tanikella | Madhura Meenakshi Tanikella is an undergraduate student from the Department of Political Science, School of Liberal Arts, Alliance University, Bengaluru. She is currently an intern at NIAS.
Pakistan’s National Commission for Minorities:
Akshath Kaimal
Escalating attacks in Pakistan:
Aarav Bhaskar
Pakistan's Compounding Water Crisis:
Dhivya KM | Dhivya KM is a Research Intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru. She is currently pursuing an MA in Financial Economics at the Madras School of Economics, with research interests spanning financial markets and geopoliti
Pakistan's Federal Budget FY2026-27:
Vani Vyshnavi Jupudi
Pakistan Economic Survey 2025-26: Six Takeaways
Vani Vyshnavi Jupudi
Pakistan's macroeconomic performance in the second quarter
Aparna A Nair
Pakistan PM in China:
Lekshmi MK | Lekshmi MK is a Research Assistant at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.
Climate Change and Pakistan's Economic Faultlines:
Dhivya KM | Dhivya K M is an intern at NIAS and is also a postgraduate student of MA Financial Economics at the Madras School of Economics, Chennai.
Pakistan's Economy in the Second Quarter:
Radhika M Agarwal | Radhika M Agarwal is a postgraduate student at the Department of Politics and International Relations in Pandit Deendayal Energy University, Gandhinagar.
The Unrest in Pakistan occupied Kashmir (PoK):Â
Nithin V | Nithin V is a postgraduate student in International Relations, with an interest in geopolitics, international political economy, and climate governance. He is currently an intern at the National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS), Bengaluru.Â
Pakistan and Press Freedom:
Akshath Kaimal
The Pakistan-Afghanistan Conflict
Abhimanyu Solanki
Escalatory Airpower, Hybrid Retaliation, and Regional Security
Akshath Kaimal
Pakistan-Afghanistan Conflict
Akshath Kaimal
Pakistan-Afghanistan Clashes
D Suba Chandran
The US-Iran Conflict and Pakistan
Akshath Kaimal
Continuing militant attacks in Balochistan
Vani Vyshnavi Jupudi
Pakistan Budget 2025-26
R Preetha
Pakistan and IMF’s Governance and Corruption Diagnostic Assessment
Abhiruchi Chowdhury
Pakistan-Afghanistan relations:
Abhiruchi Chowdhury
Pakistan-Turkiye: Looking beyond the recent visits, and bolstering defence ties
Swati Sood
Pakistan’s Budget 2025-26: Five takeaways
J Yamini
Gender Violence in Pakistan:
Brighty Ann Sarah
Child Marriage Restraint Bill in Pakistan: What is the new bill? Why is a section opposing it?
Vani Vyshnavi Jupudi
Bangladesh–Pakistan Relations:
Nuha Aamina
Cholistan Water Canal Project: Why does Punjab want it, and why is Sindh opposing?
Nuha Aamina
The Misuse of Pakistan’s Blasphemy Laws: Where, Who and Why
D Suba Chandran
Militancy, Security and Politics in Balochistan: Evaluating the early responses to BLA's train hijacking
D Suba Chandran
Militants hijack a train in Balochistan: Where, Who and Why
Abhiruchi Chowdhury
PM Sharif’s Visit to Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan: Connectivity, Defence, Energy and Politics
Nuha Aamina
Targetting the Ahmadiyas, Forced Converssions and Blasphemy Misuse: Five takeaways from HRCP report
D Suba Chandran
Continuing Suicide Attacks in Pakistan: Why, Where and Who
Rohini Reenum
Inflation reaches a decade low: Why and What next?
Rohini Reenum
Trends in Terror attacks in February: More Civilian Casualties than Military, focused on Balochistan and KP
Abhiruchi Chowdhury
The unending mayhem in Kurram
PR Team
Pakistan Reader 2024: Our Monthly Publications
Abhiruchi Chowdhury
Polio: Why is Pakistan vaccine hesitant?
Nuha Aamina
Pakistan and Climate Change: Four Takeaways
Rohini Reenum
PR Explainer: Pakistan’s Diabetes Problem
Vetriselvi Baskaran
Energy in Pakistan: Five Takeaways
Dhriti Mukherjee
JI holds sit-in against poor economic situation and controversial deals with IPPs
Vetriselvi Baskaran
A surge in attacks on girl’s school in Pakistan
Dhriti Mukherjee
Growth and Investment in Pakistan: Four Takeaways
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan: The decision to ban PTI
Rohini Reenum
Counter-terrorism, Bannu peace march, 9 May, and Digital Terrorism: What did DG ISPR say and why?
Diya Madhavan
PR Review I Pakistan Economic Survey 2024 (Part-VI)| Health and Nutrition in Pakistan: Four Takeaways
Vetriselvi Baskaran
PR Review I Pakistan Economic Survey 2024 (Part-V)| Education in Pakistan: Four Takeaways
Vaneeta
PR Review I Pakistan Economic Survey 2024 (Part-IV)| Public Debt in Pakistan: Five Takeaways
Dhriti Mukherjee
PR Review I Pakistan Economic Survey 2024 (Part-III)| Climate Change in Pakistan: Five Takeaways
Vaneeta
PR Review I Pakistan Economic Survey 2024 (Part-II)| Inflation in Pakistan: Five Takeaways
Ayan Datta
PR Review I Pakistan Economic Survey 2024 (Part-I)| Population, Labour Force and Employment in Pakistan: Six Takeaways
Rohini Reenum
The Rise of Sunni Ittehad Council (SIC) in Parliament: Four Major Takeaways
Vetriselvi Baskaran
Punjab budget 2024-25: Prioritising Health and Initiatives
Dhriti Mukherjee
Sindh Provincial Budget 2024-25: Urban and Political
Dhriti Mukherjee
Ten Years of CPEC-1 (Dasu Hydropower Project: A Profile)
Vaneeta
Defamation Bill in Punjab: Who is opposing it and why?
Kavithasri M
State of Media in Pakistan (PR Review-III) | Three Takeaways on Safety for Journalists in Pakistan
Tiara Marie Warjri
State of Media in Pakistan (PR Review-II) | Four Takeaways on Disinformation in Pakistan
Dhriti Mukherjee
Blasphemy, Harassment of Religious Minorities Continue: Five Takeaways from USCIRF Annual Report on Religious Freedoms
D Suba Chandran
Continuing Controversy over Pakistan's "Reserved Seats": Six Implications of Legal and Political Wrangling
Dhriti Mukherjee
Lawyers’ protests in Lahore: Two Reasons Why
Rohini Reenum
Protests in Pakistan Occupied Kashmir: What and Why?
Dhriti Mukherjee
9 May Violence: One Event, Different Actors, Multiple Outlooks
D Suba Chandran
The Fog of 9 May: One year after the anti-Establishment violence
Rohini Reenum
Pakistan and Wheat: From a Crisis to a Scandal
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan and Freedom of Expression: Eight Takeaways from the Freedom Network Report
D Suba Chandran
Karachi: Seven Shades of Violence
Rohini Reenum
Recurrent floods in Pakistan: What and Why
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan's Position on the War in Gaza
Rohini Reenum
Pakistan's Uncertain Economic Future: Five Takeaways from the ADB Report
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan's narrow tax base: Failures so far, challenges ahead
Dhriti Mukherjee
Profile: Street Crimes in Karachi
PR Team
Return of Nawaz Sharif: An Analysis
PR Team
Hazrat Data Ganj Bakhsh Ali Hajveri: On Sufi spirituality
PR Team
The Snow Leopards of Pakistan
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan grapples with soaring electricity bills and free riders
Femy Francis
Pakistan, US and the Cipher Controversy: The problem of an inherently asymmetric relationship
Shamini Velayutham
Pakistan: Recent spike in Polio cases
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan’s power predicament: Soaring bills and public discontent
Ankit Singh
Pakistan’s Economy: Three questions
Sneha Surendran
From Cargo to Canvas: The vibrant world of Pakistani Truck Art
D Suba Chandran
76 Years After: What Pakistan is? And who is responsible for what it is?
D. Suba Chandran
Que Sara Sara: Pakistan, Two Months After 09 May
Ankit Singh
Pakistan, IMF and China: Between debt uncertainty and geopolitical interests
Sneha Surendran
Pakistan’s e-Sport Industry: A Profile
D Suba Chandran
Election Schedule for Punjab and KP: A split judicial verdict and the complications thereof
D Suba Chandran
Peshawar Suicide Attack: Consistent TTP violence and inconsistent State reponse
Bhoomika Sesharaj
PR Explains: Pakistan’s power outage
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Pakistan’s Blue Helmets: A long-standing contribution
D Suba Chandran
Karachi: The race and new alignments for the Mayor
PR Team
Aurat March 2022, The return of cricket, Imran Khan’s maiden Russia visit, The new Gas bill
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Pakistan, US and Russia: Putin Online, Biden Offline
Sneha M
Five Risks facing Pakistan: Review of the Global Risks Report 2022
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Deepening Pakistan-Russia ties
D. Suba Chandran
Justice Ayesha: Breaking the Legal Ceiling
Ankit Singh
Monthly report of Finance Ministry paints a gloomy yet prospective outlook
Ankit Singh
Pakistan's Judiciary in 2021
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Same Page Story: Civil-Military Relations in 2021
Sneha M
Pakistan's Rail Corridor to Istanbul: Light at the end of the tunnel?
D. Suba Chandran
Pakistan's Foreign Policy in 2021
Ankit Singh
Pakistan’s economy in 2021: Major highlights
D. Suba Chandran
2021: Where the PTI scored, missed and floundered, and what it means for 2022
Sneha M
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa LB polls: Shocking yet predicted loss for PTI
Ankit Singh
Pakistan and the Asian Development Bank
Apoorva Sudhakar
The PDM is back, again
Ankit Singh
Pakistani media’s response to the Justice Saqib Nisar audio leak| Major takeaways
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Qureshi’s visit to Brussels: Three takeaways
Sneha M
Student’s Solidarity March in Pakistan: A step in the right direction
Apoorva Sudhakar
Protests in Gwadar: Four major highlights
Ankit Singh
Mini budget, IMF and a contemporary puzzle.
Ankit Singh
Indus river dolphin rescued successfully in Larkana and moved to sanctuary
Sneha M
The Strategic Trade Policy Framework: A boon or a bane?
Vishnu Prasad
Pakistan cricket: Social media an outlet for inflamed passions
Ankit Singh
Pappu Sain bids adieu to the world
Apoorva Sudhakar
Smog, pollution and more: Deteriorating air quality in Pakistan
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
PTI’s secret dealing with the TTP and TLP
Ankit Singh
Impasse over next ISI Chief over after 20 days of cordial silence
Sneha M
The fragility of Digital Media Freedom in Pakistan
D. Suba Chandran
PTI’s TLP flip-flop and a secret deal
Ankit Singh
Post IMF Review: Saudi Arabia to bolster Pakistan
Apoorva Sudhakar
The increasing curbs on digital media freedom in Pakistan
Ankit Singh
Pakistan IMF talks faces a logjam of accountability and trust
Sneha M
Pakistan’s prolonged Inflation problem
D. Suba Chandran
TLP: The government caves in again
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
TLP is back again
Apoorva Sudhakar | Project Associate, School of Conflict and Security Studies, NIAS
Pakistan’s transgender community: The long road ahead
D. Suba Chandran
Political instability in Balochistan: Another Chief Minister, another no-confidence motion
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Since January 2021: Why the US President has not called Pakistan’s Prime Minister so far?
Apoorva Sudhakar
No honour in honour killing
Sneha M
Pakistan's Hydropower Sector: Contribution, Challenges and Prospects
D. Suba Chandran
Appointing the new ISI Chief: Why is Imran Khan delaying the notification? Who will blink?
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
The Military Reshuffle: A strategic or routine decision?
D. Suba Chandran
Dr AQ Khan: Between a national hero and a nuclear proliferator
Ankit Singh
Tax avoidance: From Panama papers to Pandora Papers
Apoorva Sudhakar
Rising child abuse in Pakistan: Five reasons why
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Hazara Persecution in Pakistan: No end in sight
D. Suba Chandran
Talking to the Pakistani Taliban: What did Imran say? And what does it mean?
D. Suba Chandran
Protests in Gwadar: Who and Why
Juan Mary Joseph
Attacks on Chinese Investments in Pakistan: Who, Where And Why?
Lokendra Sharma
Pakistan's civil nuclear programme: Ambitious expansion plans to face multiple challenges
Apoorva Sudhakar
Digital Pakistan: Idea, Potential and Challenges
D. Suba Chandran
