NIAS Area Studies
PAKISTAN READER
Photo : CGTN
IN FOCUS
By Avishka Ashok
The US-ASEAN Summit: Why China is anxious
On 12 and 13 May, the US held the US-Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Special Summit in Washington DC. The Summit celebrated 45 years of the US-ASEAN partnership, looked into the future of the relationship and the significance of the US in the region, which has been increasingly dominated by China. The summit focused on economic recovery, health security, climate change, green energy, pandemic recovery, supporting gender equality and women’s empowerment and strengthening the people-to-people exchanges.
ASEAN’s growing importance in the world
The ASEAN countries have been at the centre of fast economic growth and hold potential to further augment the global trade and economic development. According to a report by McKinsey in 2014, the ASEAN region was one of the fastest growing trading hubs along with having an equally significant and diverse consumer market. The ten countries’ trade value accounted for USD 2.4 trillion in 2013. The vast markets enable incessant product demand while the geographic location of the countries make it a vital trading destination along the maritime trading routes.
China’s close relations with ASEAN
The China-ASEAN Summit which took place on 22 November 2021 celebrated the 30th anniversary of their relations. Through the Summit, China expanded its influence in the region and strengthened its economic ties with the ten Southeast Asian countries. China established diplomatic relations with the countries in the region in 1991 and ever since, the trade ties have improved exponentially. The trade between China and ASEAN valued USD 684.6 billion in 2020 which the US-ASEAN trade totaled at USD 362.2 billion. Thus, China economic ties with the region has made it an important partner. China also views ASEAN as a vital economic partner as it ranked first as Beijing’s largest trading partner. Moreover, international initiatives such as the Belt and Road Initiative, Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank have brought China and ASEAN closer because of the deep economic and financial ties with each other.
China’s perspectives on the summit
China does not view the US-ASEAN summit in a positive light and has expressed its discontent with the political and economic interference of the US in the region. On 12 May, China’s Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Zhao Lijian referred to the summit and urged the US to play a positive and constructive role in the region instead of causing discord. Zhao said: “The United States should not use cooperation as a cover to force others to pick sides, or play with fire on issues concerning China's core interests.”
China has criticized the US-ASEAN summit for the following reasons:
First, the heightened US presence in the region is a part of the US strategy on the Indo-Pacific. China views the summit as the Biden administration’s ticket into the region and fears that the spike in interest is a part of the US strategy on the Indo-Pacific. The Chinese government expects heightened involvement of the US in the Indo-Pacific region and has cautioned the Southeast Asian countries that the US was only trying to get even with China by using ASEAN as a tool against it. Chinese media agencies have highlighted the positive response from countries like Indonesia, Vietnam and Cambodia to the summit. The heads of state of these countries clarified their stance on the cooperation and refused to take sides. Cambodia’s Prime Minister Samdech techo Hun Sen said: “We don't have to choose between the US and China.”
Second, the US has its selfish interests in the region. At the summit, the US pledged investments worth USD 150 million. However, Chinese analysts expect USD 60 million to be spent only on assisting US partners in establishing and maintaining maritime defense. Political analysts view this expenditure as an attempt to control the South China Sea through the Southeast Asian countries. The US has also been criticized for its one-track objective of focusing on security or creating a resistance against China’s influence in the region while talking about other objectives such as clean energy, climate change, education, gender equality and more. Chinese media agencies also stressed on the US tendency to take decisions unilaterally without considering other countries and their convenience. The US was accused of single-handedly deciding a date for the summit; which later had to be postponed as all leaders were not available on the previously mentioned dates. The actions of the US displayed it exclusive mindset, according to Global Times.
Why does China oppose US involvement in ASEAN?
First, the economic balance in Southeast Asia. Since the establishment of diplomatic relations with ASEAN in 1991 and then acquiring the full dialogue partner status in 1996, China and the ten ASEAN member countries have closely depended on each other’s trade, markets, manufacturing hubs and service sectors. Since 2009, China has continued to remain ASEAN’s largest trading partner. According to the data revealed by the Chinese government, ASEAN ranked first in terms of trade in the January-April 2022 period, followed by the EU and then the US. Although the US already maintains extensive relations with the countries along various diverse fields, China is reluctant to give up one of its most secure centres of economic activities. Increased US presence may pit the Chinese and American goods and services against each other, yet again.
Second, the political interference. The US President Joe Biden’s primary policy focus has been on the Indo-Pacific region and countering the growing Chinese influence in both, global politics as well as the global economy. China is aware of the US intentions and thus, wants to restrict its presence close to its territory. Moreover, the US interference in what China considers to be its internal affairs, such as the violation of human rights in the Xinjiang Autonomous Region and Tibet, the implementation of the National Security Act in Hong Kong, the issues in the Taiwan Strait and the aggression in the South China Sea has further irked the Chinese government into drawing clear boundaries while deal with the US. China, therefore, believes that the US aims to meddle in its affairs while hiding behind the ASEAN countries.
References:
“China-ASEAN relations expand into comprehensive strategic partnership,” Asian News International, 22 November 2021
“China urges U.S. to promote regional peace, stability at upcoming U.S.-ASEAN summit,” Xinhua Net, 12 May 2022
“U.S.-ASEAN Summit,” United States Department of State
“Understanding ASEAN: Seven things you need to know,” McKinsey, 01 May 2014
“ASEAN not a tool of US in its game against China: Global Times editorial,” Global Times, 15 May 2022
“ASEAN gets to know China's inclusiveness versus US' egoism,” Global Times, 15 May 2022
“ASEAN-China Economic Relation,” ASEAN
IN BRIEF
By Avishka Ashok
INTERNAL
Social Media: Tencent founder shares his opinion on the Chinese economy
On 23 May, the Economic Times reported that the founder of Tencent Holdings Pony Ma had caused a social media stir after he shared an article on the Chinese economy, a topic that has become increasingly sensitive within the country. The article shared by Pony on his WeChat moments feed highlighted that very few people spoke of the economic pressures and challenges facing China. Ma shared a part of the article and condemned the anti-capitalists and double standards of the people criticising the economy. The paragraph highlighted by Pony said: “The way some netizens care about the economy is: Firms can go bankrupt, but they cannot fire staff; firms can go bankrupt, but they cannot have overtime work. Of course if they order delivery and it's late by 10 minutes, they will curse, and will scold the delivery rider harsher than anyone else." (“china economy: Tencent chief causes stir with repost of article on China's economy,” The Economic Times, 23 May 2022)
REGIONAL
Japan: QUAD leaders prep to meet in Tokyo and discuss the Taiwan issue, South China Sea and the Indo-Pacific
On 24 May, the leaders of the Quad group of countries met in Tokyo and discussed their goal of countering China in the Indo-Pacific region. On 23 May, the US President Joe Biden warned China against beefing up its military presence in the region and around Taiwan. He also pledged to intervene militarily in case of an invasion and expressed his hope in the grouping. He said: “The Quad is showing the world that cooperation among democracies can get big things done.” Japan has also officially cautioned China against unilaterally changing the status quo in the region, especially with respect to the Senkaku or Diaoyu islands. The grouping is also expected to release a joint statement on the war in Ukraine. (“Japan hosts Quad summit seeking unity on countering China,” The Strait Times, 23 May 2022)
INTERNATIONAL
World Economic Forum: Chinese delegation accuses CNN of false report
On 24 May, Xinhua Net accused CNN of vilifying the Chinese delegation attending the World Economic Forum’s annual meeting in Davos, Switzerland. The CNN quoted a US politician and said that the Chinese delegation did not stand in respect after Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s speech at the meeting and instead left the venue. The delegation from China opposed the reports and said that they were in conversation with the International Energy Agency Executive Direcetor Faith Birol during Zelensky’s speech. (“Chinese delegation to World Economic Forum vilified by CNN's false report,” Xinhua Net, 24 May 2022)
BRICS: Industry Ministers discuss new industrial revolution
On 23 May, the Industry Ministers of the BRICS countries held a virtual meeting and agreed to cooperate on deepening innovation on new industrial revolution and resiliently working towards achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. The meeting was hosted by China in Xiamen city in the Fujian province and provided a platform to discuss comprehensive cooperation, digital transformation of traditional industries and industrial and supply chain collaboration between the member countries. China’s Minister of Industry and Information Technology Xiao Yaqing observed the progress made by the countries since the first meeting and encouraged future cooperation on the same. He said: “China stands ready to work with all parties to deepen innovative cooperation on the new industrial revolution for achieving sustainable development goals in a stronger, healthier and more resilient manner.” (“BRICS ministers urge cooperation on new industrial revolution,” Xinhua Net, 24 May 2022)
United Nations: Wang Yi meets High Commissioner for Human Rights
On 23 May, Foreign Minister Wang Yi held a meeting with the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet in Guangzhou, the latter’s first visit to China. Wang Yi welcomed Bachelet and noted that her visit marks the first visit by a UN High Commissioner for human rights in 17 years. Wang Yi also stressed on the Communist Party of China’s people centric approach and said: “China has always prioritized the rights to subsistence and development, protected citizens' legitimate rights and interests, and safeguarded the rights of ethnic minorities. While vigorously advancing its own human rights cause, China advocates the universal values of peace, development, fairness, justice, democracy and freedom.” (“Chinese FM meets UN human rights chief,” Xinhua Net, 24 May 2022)
Brazil: China co-chairs High-Level Coordination and Cooperation Committee
On 23 May, China’s Vice President Wang Qishan and Brazil’s Vice President Hamilton Mourao co-chaired the sixth China-Brazil High-Level Coordination and Cooperation Committee (COSBAN) meeting. Wang noted the bilateral cooperation and said: “China and Brazil have been accommodating each other's fundamental and long-term interests, and have worked together to counter global challenges, writing a new chapter of cooperation between emerging economies.” He also encouraged the communication between the countries on major international and regional issues and called for facilitation of common interests of the emerging markets. (“Vice presidents of China, Brazil co-chair COSBAN meeting,” Xinhua Net, 24 May 2022)